Home » Featured, Manage Money Online, health care

ORDERING FROM THE MENU AT YOUR NEXT DOCTORS VISIT

3 April 2009 318 views One Comment

hypodermicneedleThe first time I took my kid to the emergency room was an unforgettable experience. It was the middle of the night; he’d fallen off the bed at someone else’s house and bumped his head. After waiting for hours, we were finally seen by the MD on duty who asked me a surprising question; “Do you want us to give your son an MRI?” I blinked. Who’s the doc here I wondered? “What would you do if this was your son?” I asked. Very diplomatically, he told me to skip the MRI and just get the stitches. That was the right decision; our son was fine and didn’t need the MRI after all.

After reflecting on that moment, I was glad the Doc gave us a choice. That MRI would have cost thousands, the insurance company would pick up some of the tab, and I would have been left with a large bill for an unnecessary expense.

I wish all of visits worked out that nicely. Recently, our other son had to visit the pediatrician and was prescribed a month-long treatment of medicine. We picked up the first prescription, a 6 day supply, and it costs us $90. Before filling the next week’s prescription, we checked with the pediatrician’s office and found out there was a generic available for only $7. Why hadn’t our doctor’s office prescribed the generic in the first place?

I have a solution for the outrageous costs of healthcare in our country; doctors’ offices need menus. Would you order off a restaurant’s menu at if they didn’t list their prices? Why are doctor’s offices different? After all, they are businesses too.

Why aren’t we made aware of the costs before we approve of the care?  The pharmaceutical companies tell us what to ask doctors for, so why not tell us the price as well?  Doctors and dentists advertise to attract new customers. So why shouldn’t we know the prices and be able to comparison shop?

Opponents will tell you this will prevent people from getting the primary care they need, because they’ll be concerned about the cost. If that is true, then people concerned about costs may already be skipping necessary visits. Isn’t it better to know upfront what the costs will be and make an informed decision, rather than be surprised (or angered) later after the choice has been made?

Here are a few tips to getting the most for your money when visiting the doctor, dentist, or ophthalmologist:

  1. Call ahead and request pricing information. Likely, offices will resistant to giving out their prices before you’re seen. Press them for information anyhow. After all, it’s your money.
  2. Shop around. Who says you have to see the same doctor each time?
  3. Ask for a cash discount. We have been able to get as much as 30% knocked off the cost of some visits simply be paying cash. It saves offices the hassle and delay of getting reimbursements from insurance companies.
  4. Consider lower cost alternatives. Ask for a nurse practitioner instead of a doctor next time. Or consider one of the Minute Clinics at CVS. You can get some nice savings from either.

It’s not that I dislike doctors. I have several friends that are MD’s and they always pay when we go out. It’s simply about competitive pricing, like every other purchase we make.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

One Comment »

  • bmcbride said:

    Good stuff! I am convinced that lack of price awareness is what is driving a good deal of medical inflation.

    The insurance plan (public or private) that pays everything and makes you blissfully unaware of the cost feels nice, but in insulating us from the cost of our consumption, it makes us consume more and pay more.

    I think there must be a rational way to think about medical care from a perspective that recognizes it as an economic decision. In other words, there are only so many dollars to go around (in a family budget or a country), so if you buy more of one thing, you must buy less of another. What if the MRI cost $100? What if the MRI cost a trillion dollars? I know we’re talking about human life, but in the end, doesn’t cost enter in to the equation somewhere?

    I would love what true competition could bring to medical prices. Hasn’t Lasik come way down in price, precisely because you can’t get insurance to pay for it and so practitioners go out and earn your business? Maybe MRIs could actually cost $100 someday.

    And, at the end of the day, aren’t you glad to have the ability to ask your MD what he would do, and have the choice what care to give your son?

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.